Garmin Forerunner 170 Music vs Garmin Forerunner 405CX

Every spec side by side, from each maker's published figures.

Better figure, where one is clearly better

Forerunner 170 Music compared with Forerunner 405CX
GarminForerunner 170 MusicGarminForerunner 405CX
Overview
ReleasedMay 20262009
Display
Case sizes42.6 mm47.75 mm
PanelOLED–
Always-on displayYesYes
Display detail1.2-inch (30.4 mm diameter) colour AMOLED touchscreen, 390 x 390 pixels; optional always-on display and large-font setting; five physical buttonsBacklit monochrome screen, 27 mm diagonal and 124 × 95 pixels; touch-sensitive bezel and two buttons. Panel technology is unpublished in the maker's specification.
Screen protectionChemically strengthened glass–
Health and fitness
ECGNoNo
Blood oxygenYesNo
Skin temperatureNoNo
Sleep apnoea alertsNoNo
High blood pressure alertsNoNo
Body compositionNoNo
Fall detectionNoNo
Crash detectionNoNo
GPSSingle-bandSingle-band
Water resistance50 m–
SensorsGarmin Elevate wrist heart rate; Pulse Ox; barometric altimeter; compass; gyroscope; accelerometer; thermometer; ambient light sensor; thermometer measures activity/ambient temperature, not overnight skin temperatureHigh-sensitivity GPS receiver with HotFix; ANT+ heart-rate chest strap, optional foot pod and cycling speed/cadence sensor. No optical wrist sensor.
Health featuresContinuous heart rate with high/low alerts; HRV status; Body Battery; stress and respiration; advanced sleep, sleep coach, breathing variations and nap detection; meditation; smart wake alarm; Health Snapshot; lifestyle logging; Health Status; women's health tracking via Garmin Connect; no ECG app–
Fitness featuresMore than 80 sports apps; training readiness, status, load, load focus and recovery time; Garmin running, cycling and strength coaching; daily suggested running workouts and quick workouts; wrist-based running dynamics and running power; ground-contact balance requires a compatible accessory; PacePro and grade-adjusted pace; VO2 max and race predictions; cycling power-meter and Varia radar/light support; pool and open-water swimming; no dedicated triathlon mode; Breadcrumb course navigation, point-to-point navigation, back-to-start and TracBack; elevation profile, future elevation plot and Up Ahead; no full routable offline mapsHeart-rate-based calorie calculation developed with Firstbeat; custom and interval workouts, courses, Virtual Partner, Auto Lap, Auto Pause, Auto Scroll and configurable training screens.
Safety featuresIncident detection during selected activities, assistance and LiveTrack require a paired compatible smartphone; live event sharing is Android-only; screen flashlight, not a separate LED torchUp to 100 stored locations and navigation to a saved location; no base maps.
Battery and connections
Battery life (maker's claim)Up to 10 daysUp to 8 hours
In low-power modeUp to 19 daysUp to 14 days
Mobile data optionNoNo
Works withiPhone and AndroidNo phone pairing
Storage4 GB–
Battery life detailSmartwatch up to 10 days, or 4 days with display always on; battery saver smartwatch up to 19 days; GPS-only GNSS up to 20 hours; all-systems GNSS up to 14 hours; with music, GPS-only up to 7.5 hours and all-systems up to 6.5 hours (exact series manual; UK web table mislabels 7.5 hours as days); actual life depends on enabled features and usageRechargeable 300 mAh lithium-ion battery; up to eight hours with GPS or two weeks in power-save mode, according to the English owner's manual. Garmin Slovakia instead quotes nine GPS hours.
ChargingGarmin proprietary plug charging/data cable; rechargeable built-in lithium-ion battery; USB charging temperature 0–45 °CUSB contact charging clip and AC adapter.
ConnectivityBluetooth, ANT+ and Wi-Fi; GPS, GLONASS and Galileo; no multi-band GNSS; Garmin Pay contactless payments; Android-only text responses and notification images; Connect IQ apps/watch faces/data fields; Garmin Share; controls smartphone music and plays downloaded personal audio or supported music-service content through compatible Bluetooth headphones; third-party services may require subscriptions; no speaker/microphone calls or cellular connectionANT+ computer transfers through a USB ANT stick; Garmin Connect and Garmin Training Center. No direct phone pairing.
Storage4 GB memory/history with offline music supportUp to 1,000 laps, 100 locations and approximately twenty hours of track points at one point every four seconds.
Design
Weight (lightest version)41 g (better)60 g
SoftwareGarminGarmin
Case materialsFibre-reinforced polymer bezel; silicone band; chemically strengthened glass; 5 ATM water rating; operating/storage temperature –20–60 °CIPX7 immersion protection, one metre for thirty minutes; the manual says the watch is not intended for swimming.
Size42.6 x 42.6 x 11.9 mm; Garmin lists 41 g without a separate body-only weight47.75 × 70.5 × 16.4 mm and 60 g, according to the English manual; Garmin Slovakia rounds this to 48 × 71 × 16 mm. Width is used as the case size.
BandsStandard 20 mm quick-release two-tone silicone band; fits 126–203 mm wristsStandard wrist strap and two additional form-fitting fabric straps for smaller or larger wrists.
ColoursBlack with Black/Amp Yellow band; Whitestone with Whitestone/Cloud Blue band; Teal Green with Teal Green/Citron band; Red Pink with Red Pink/Mango bandDeep blue.
In the boxForerunner 170 Music; charging cable; documentationWatch, heart-rate chest strap, USB ANT stick, AC adapter, USB charging clip, additional wrist straps and documentation.

More comparisons