Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8G vs Nikon NIKKOR Z 28-135mm f/4 PZ

Every spec side by side, from each maker's published figures.

Better figure, where one is clearly better

AF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8G compared with NIKKOR Z 28-135mm f/4 PZ
NikonAF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8GNikonNIKKOR Z 28-135mm f/4 PZ
Overview
ReleasedJune 2011April 2025
Optics
Lens typePrimeZoom
Focal length50 mm28–135 mm
Maximum aperturef/1.8f/4
Minimum aperturef/16f/22
Optical constructionSeven elements in six groups18 elements in 13 groups
Special elementsOne aspherical elementThree ED elements, one aspherical ED element and four aspherical elements
CoatingsSuper Integrated CoatingMeso Amorphous Coat and fluorine coating on the front element
Aperture detailf/1.8–16; no aperture ring–
DiaphragmSeven rounded bladesNine rounded blades
Angle of viewFX 47°; DX 31°30′FX 75° to 18°10′; DX 53° to 12°
Mount and compatibility
MountsNikon F mountNikon Z mount
Image circleFull frameFull frame
CompatibilityNikon F mount; full-frame/FX coverage, also usable on DX cameras. Built-in autofocus motor supports Nikon DSLRs without an in-body focus motor, as Photography Blog confirms–
Focus and stabilisation
AutofocusYesYes
Minimum focus distance0.45 m0.34 m
Maximum magnification0.15×0.25×
Optical stabilisationNoNo
Autofocus detailSilent Wave Motor with manual focus overrideStepping motor autofocus and internal focusing
Focus distance detailMinimum 0.45 m; Photography Blog confirms the outer barrel's length stays unchanged and the filter thread does not rotate during focusing, while noting this is not a true internal-focus lensMinimum focal-plane distances of 0.34 m at 28, 35 and 50 mm; 0.39 m at 70 mm; 0.43 m at 85 mm; 0.49 m at 105 mm; 0.57 m at 135 mm
Magnification detailMaximum 0.15×; not a life-size macro lensMaximum reproduction ratio 0.25× at 55–135 mm
Stabilisation detailNo lens optical VRNo optical VR, confirmed by Digital Camera World; camera stabilisation depends on the body
Video features–Focus-breathing suppression, linear manual-focus support and power zoom; Hi-Res Zoom synchronisation requires a supported camera and suitable firmware
Design
Dust and moisture resistant–Yes
Filter diameter58 mm95 mm
Maximum diameter72 mm105 mm
Length52.5 mm177.5 mm
Weight185 g (better)1,210 g
ControlsManual focus ring, M/A–M switch and focus-distance window; Photography Blog notes depth-of-field markings for f/16 only and no focus limiterZoom rocker, electronically coupled zoom and focus rings, customisable control ring, two L-Fn buttons and A–M switch; no mechanically driven manual zoom ring
Zoom design–Internal power zoom with eleven selectable speeds on compatible cameras; adjustable zoom-ring direction and rotation angle, with firmware and camera compatibility requirements
Filter detail58 mm screw-in filters95 mm screw-in filter thread; HB-116 rectangular hood has a filter adjustment window
Weather resistanceBoth reviews confirm a rubber seal at the metal mount. Broader barrel sealing is not established, so no general weather-resistance rating is assignedMaker dust and drip-resistant design; protection is not guaranteed in every condition
Dimensions detailApproximately 72 mm maximum diameter × 52.5 mm lengthApproximately 105 mm maximum diameter × 177.5 mm from the mount flange
Weight detailApproximately 185 g according to Nikon; Photography Blog reports 187 g, which is not substituted for the maker figureApproximately 1,210 g including tripod collar, used in the main specifications; approximately 1,120 g without it
Tripod mount–Tripod collar with removable foot
Lens hoodHB-47 included–
In the boxLC-58 front cap, LF-4 rear cap, HB-47 bayonet hood and CL-1013 pouchLC-95B front cap, LF-N1 rear cap, HB-116 hood and CL-C5 case
Release detailNikon USA's April 2011 announcement states 16 June availability. Earliest exact global and first UK day unconfirmed, so June precision retained. Photography Blog's URL includes DX and its image captions refer to 24mm, but the actual review tests this FX 50mm f/1.8GNikon USA specified April 2025 retail availability; the February announcement date is not used as the on-sale date

More comparisons