Panasonic VIERA G10 vs Panasonic VIERA S30
Better figure, where one is clearly better
| PanasonicVIERA G10 | PanasonicVIERA S30 | |
|---|---|---|
| Overview | ||
| Released | 2009 | 2011 |
| Display | ||
| Panel | Plasma | Plasma |
| Panel detail | Panasonic's UK TX-P42G10B, TX-P46G10B and TX-P50G10B manual specifies native Full HD NeoPDP plasma panels. Its 600 Hz sub-field drive branding does not establish the native image refresh rate, which is left unpublished here. | Panasonic's exact UK 42-inch and 50-inch manuals identify Full HD plasma panels. The 600 Hz sub-field processing claim is not a native frame refresh rate. |
| Resolution | 1920 × 1080 (Full HD) | 1920 × 1080 (Full HD) |
| HDR formats | None | None |
| Picture processing | NeoPDP panel with Panasonic Intelligent Frame Creation, colour management and 3D-COMB. The UK set's user menus do not expose white-balance or gamma controls, unlike the European G10E according to HDTVTest. | True Cinema mode and Intelligent Frame Creation. Unlike the G30, the S30 has no user-accessible white-balance, gamma or colour-management controls. |
| Picture modes | Dynamic, Normal, Cinema and Game, with separate picture-mode settings and an Eco ambient-light option within each mode. | Dynamic, Normal, Cinema, True Cinema and Game modes described in the UK manual. |
| Motion handling | HDTVTest identifies a 600 Hz sub-field drive for the NeoPDP panel; this is a drive technique, not the native frame refresh. It found good motion clarity with Intelligent Frame Creation off and no telecine judder from 1080p/24 HDMI input. | The two full reviews report fast gaming response on their 42-inch UK review samples, while noting some 50 Hz artefacts and slight brightness fluctuations. These observations have not been verified on the 50-inch size. |
| Sizes | ||
| Sizes | 42, 46, 50″ | 42, 50″ |
| Largest size | 50″ | 50″ |
| Gaming | ||
| HDMI ports | 3 (0 HDMI 2.1 at 4K 120 Hz+) | 3 (0 HDMI 2.1 at 4K 120 Hz+) |
| Variable refresh rate | None | None |
| HDMI detail | Three HDMI Type A 1.3a inputs with x.v.Colour and VIERA Link HDAVI Control 4. Also two RGB SCART inputs, component video and D-sub PC input; SD card slot for photos. Input timing and PC scanning frequencies are not native refresh specifications. | Three HDMI Type A inputs, with HDMI2 supporting Audio Return Channel. The exact 42-inch UK manual also lists one RGB SCART, component and composite inputs. |
| Smart TV and sound | ||
| Smart TV platform | None (no smart platform) | VIERA Connect |
| Speakers | 20 W | 20 W |
| Speaker detail | Two 160 × 40 mm, 6-ohm speakers; 10 W + 10 W at 10% THD. | The 42-inch UK manual specifies two 160 × 40 mm speakers rated 10 W + 10 W. The 50-inch speaker construction was not verified separately. |
| Audio features | V-Audio Surround, optical PCM/Dolby Digital output, analogue RCA stereo output and 3.5 mm headphone socket. | The 42-inch UK manual lists analogue stereo, optical digital audio and a 3.5 mm headphone socket. |
| Casting | – | VIERA Connect and DLNA over Ethernet; optional wireless LAN adaptor. |
| Software updates | DVB broadcast software updates; no VIERA Cast internet app platform on the UK G10 series. | – |
| TV tuners | UK Freesat HD DVB-S/S2 satellite input, DVB-T terrestrial and PAL I analogue UHF. Freesat services use the Ethernet socket; it does not make the television an internet app platform. | UK Freeview HD DVB-T2, DVB-T and PAL I analogue terrestrial tuning; no satellite tuner. |
| USB | – | Two USB 2.0 ports and SD card slot. The 42-inch UK manual describes media playback; no USB hard-drive recording claim is made here. |
| Ethernet | RJ45 10BASE-T/100BASE-TX for Freesat network services. | RJ45 Ethernet for VIERA Connect and DLNA services. |
| Optical audio out | Optical PCM and Dolby Digital output. | The 42-inch UK manual lists optical PCM, Dolby Digital and DTS output. |
| Design and power | ||
| Size | Panasonic TV-only dimensions, width × height × depth: 42-inch 1029 × 661 × 106 mm, 25 kg; 46-inch 1132 × 722 × 106 mm, 29 kg; 50-inch 1218 × 769 × 106 mm, 32 kg. With supplied pedestal: 1029 × 704 × 334 mm, 28 kg; 1132 × 767 × 401 mm, 32 kg; 1218 × 814 × 401 mm, 35 kg respectively. | The exact TX-P42S30B manual gives 1023 × 637 × 93 mm and 20 kg TV-only, or 1023 × 671 × 288 mm and 23 kg with pedestal. The 50-inch dimensions are omitted pending a verified exact figure. |
| Stand | Pedestal supplied; 42-inch and 46/50-inch use different Panasonic pedestal part numbers. Wall mounting is optional. | Rectangular pedestal supplied. |
| Power use | Panasonic rated power consumption: 350 W (42-inch), 410 W (46-inch), 435 W (50-inch). Standby is 0.4 W without monitor-output recording and 32 W with it. HDTVTest measured 181 W in factory Standard mode and 235 W after calibration on the 42-inch set; these are test conditions, not maker ratings. | Panasonic rates the TX-P42S30B at 255 W, with 0.30 W standby or 16 W with monitor-out recording. The 50-inch figure is omitted pending verification. |
| Colours | Gloss black bezel with silver lower accent. | – |
| In the box | N2QAYB000428 remote, two R6 batteries, pedestal, cable clamper, mains lead, two ferrite cores, cleaning cloth, instructions and guarantee documents. HDTVTest said the UK model was available to buy by 15 April 2009, while What Hi-Fi? had reviewed it on 30 March; these sources do not establish the earliest on-sale month, so the release field uses year precision. | The 42-inch UK manual lists remote control, two batteries, pedestal and mains lead. Panasonic's UK 2011 tuner list identifies the separate TX-P42S30B and TX-P50S30B; an exact first-sale month has not been verified. |
More comparisons
- Panasonic VIERA G10 vs Panasonic Z95B
- Panasonic VIERA S30 vs Panasonic Z90B
- Panasonic VIERA DX802 vs Panasonic VIERA S30
- Panasonic VIERA DX802 vs Panasonic VIERA G10
- Panasonic VIERA DX902 vs Panasonic VIERA S30
- Panasonic VIERA DX902 vs Panasonic VIERA G10
- Panasonic VIERA CX802 vs Panasonic VIERA S30
- Panasonic VIERA CX802 vs Panasonic VIERA G10
- Panasonic VIERA AX902 vs Panasonic VIERA S30
- Panasonic VIERA AX902 vs Panasonic VIERA G10
- Panasonic VIERA G10 vs Panasonic VIERA GT60
- Panasonic VIERA G10 vs Panasonic VIERA ST60
- Panasonic VIERA GT60 vs Panasonic VIERA S30
- Panasonic VIERA S30 vs Panasonic VIERA ST60
- Panasonic VIERA S30 vs Panasonic VIERA VT60
- Panasonic VIERA S30 vs Panasonic VIERA ZT65

