Apple Apple Keyboard (compact, 2009) vs Apple Magic Keyboard (2015, Lightning)

Every spec side by side, from each maker's published figures.

Better figure, where one is clearly better

Apple Keyboard (compact, 2009) compared with Magic Keyboard (2015, Lightning)
AppleApple Keyboard (compact, 2009)AppleMagic Keyboard (2015, Lightning)
Overview
ReleasedMarch 2009October 2015
Typing
LayoutCompactCompact
SwitchesScissorScissor
BacklightNoneNone
Keys labelled forMacMac
Touch IDNoNo
SwitchesLow-profile scissor keys; Deskthority identifies the mechanism for Apple's aluminium keyboard family.Revised scissor mechanism; Apple's launch announcement describes a lower profile and increased key stability
LayoutsCompact layout without a numeric keypad or separate navigation cluster; inverted-T arrow keys sit below the right Shift key.–
Special keysTwelve function keys with brightness, media playback, volume and eject controls.Multimedia function keys; half-height up and down arrows beside full-height left and right arrows, described by AppleInsider
Connections and battery
Connects byCableBluetooth
Devices it switches between–1
PowerCableRechargeable
Battery life detail–About a month or more between charges, according to Apple; tested in September 2015 with preproduction keyboards and shipping iMacs. Not an upper-bound battery-life claim.
Charging–Built-in rechargeable battery; Lightning-to-USB cable charges and automatically pairs with a Mac. Macworld confirms the keyboard can remain in use while plugged in.
ReceiverCaptive USB cable and one USB 2.0 port on each side of the keyboard.–
Works withThe default keyboard supplied with the iMac line that Apple began shipping on 3 March 2009.Bluetooth-enabled Mac with OS X 10.11 or later; iOS devices running iOS 9.1 or later, according to the retained original specification
Design
Weight–231 g
Width × depth × height–279 × 114.9 × 10.9 mm
Size–Height 0.41–1.09 cm, width 27.9 cm and depth 11.49 cm; Apple's 0.231 kg weight varies by configuration and manufacturing process
MaterialsSilver aluminium enclosure with white low-profile keys.Aluminium body, plastic keys and underside, described by AppleInsider
ColoursSilver and white.Silver body with white keys
In the boxIncluded with the 2009 iMac; also offered separately, according to Macworld.Magic Keyboard and Lightning-to-USB cable. This entry covers the original 2015 model, distinct from later Lock-key, Touch ID and USB-C models.

More comparisons