Beurer BC 54 vs Omron RS3 Intelli IT
Better figure, where one is clearly better
| BeurerBC 54 | OmronRS3 Intelli IT | |
|---|---|---|
| Overview | ||
| Released | – | – |
| Measuring | ||
| Type | Wrist | Wrist |
| Clinically validated | – | Yes |
| Irregular heartbeat detection | Yes | Yes |
| AFib detection or ECG | – | No |
| Method | Automatic oscillometric wrist measurement during inflation; first on-sale date not established | Oscillometric wrist measurement; HEM-6161T-E. First on-sale date not established |
| Accuracy | Maker manual specifies display accuracy of ±3 mmHg for systolic and diastolic pressure and ±5% of the displayed pulse value; this is distinct from independent clinical validation | Maker's pressure accuracy ±3 mmHg and pulse accuracy ±5%; systolic range 60–260 mmHg, diastolic 40–215 mmHg and pulse 40–180 beats/minute |
| Clinical validation | Beurer states clinical testing to ISO 81060-2 in the current manual and an ESH validation claim in its datasheet | Medaval attributes STRIDE BP adult self-measurement recommendation to HEM-6181 equivalence, noting that the unpublished assessment cannot be verified against MDR requirements. Exact manual says pregnancy use has not been validated |
| Features | Coloured risk scale, irregular heartbeat warning, date/time and automatic switch-off; maker lists no position or resting indicator | Cuff-wrap, hypertension and irregular-heartbeat indicators; no advanced wrist-height sensor, movement indicator, averaging, AFib screening or ECG. Web FAQ positioning wording does not establish a sensor |
| Cuff | ||
| Cuff fits | 13.5–21.5 cm | 13.5–21.5 cm |
| Cuff | Attached wrist cuff | Wrist circumference 13.5–21.5 cm |
| Connections and memory | ||
| Users | 2 (better) | 1 |
| Readings stored | 60 per user (better) | 30 |
| Bluetooth and app | Yes | Yes |
| Memory | Average of all saved measurements and morning/evening averages for the last seven days | Up to 30 internal readings for one user; stored results transfer to the app. The exact instructions do not describe browsing earlier readings on the monitor |
| App | Bluetooth transfer to the free beurer HealthManager Pro app | Bluetooth low energy transfers readings to OMRON connect automatically within one hour or manually using the Bluetooth button; device compatibility depends on the app |
| Power | Two 1.5 V LR03 AAA batteries; maker claims approximately 150 measurements depending on pressure and Bluetooth use | Two AAA alkaline batteries included; approximately 300 measurements with new alkaline batteries |
| Design | ||
| Display details | Illuminated LCD, 4.7 × 4.5 cm; white digits on a black background | Digital LCD; IP22 |
| Size | 8.00 × 6.90 × 7.60 cm (L × W × H), current maker product page | Approximately 84 × 62 × 21 mm (W × H × L, excluding cuff); 2022 manual gives 85 g without batteries, versus web table's rounded 90 g |
| In the box | Wrist monitor, two AAA batteries, storage box, quick guide and blood pressure pass | Monitor, two AAA alkaline batteries, storage case, instruction manual and setup instructions |
