BMW Z4 vs Mercedes-Benz A-Class Hatchback
Better figure, where one is clearly better
| BMWZ4 | Mercedes-BenzA-Class Hatchback | |
|---|---|---|
| Overview | ||
| Released | October 2018 | May 2018 |
| Performance | ||
| Powertrain | Petrol | Mild hybrid, Petrol |
| Power | 194–335 bhp | 134–416 bhp (better) |
| 0–62 mph | 4.5–6.6 s | 3.9–9.2 s (better) |
| Top speed | 149–155 mph | 134–168 mph (better) |
| Engine or motors | sDrive20i: 1,998 cc four-cylinder turbo petrol, 145 kW (197 hp); M40i: 2,998 cc six-cylinder turbo petrol, 250 kW (340 hp); bhp converted from BMW's kW figures | A 180: 1,332 cc four-cylinder turbo petrol with 48 V mild hybrid, 100 kW (136 hp) + 10 kW; A 35: 1,991 cc four-cylinder, 225 kW (306 hp) + 10 kW mild hybrid; A 45 S: 1,991 cc four-cylinder, 310 kW (421 hp); bhp converted from Mercedes' kW figures |
| Torque | 320 Nm (sDrive20i), 500 Nm (M40i) | 230 Nm (A 180), 400 Nm (A 35), 500 Nm (A 45 S) |
| Gearbox | 8-speed automatic | 7G-DCT dual-clutch automatic (A 180); 8G-DCT (A 35); AMG SPEEDSHIFT DCT 8G (A 45 S) |
| Drive | Rear-wheel drive | Front-wheel drive (A 180); 4MATIC all-wheel drive (AMG) |
| Range and charging | ||
| Economy (WLTP) | 35.3–39.8 mpg | 30.8–48.8 mpg (better) |
| Efficiency | WLTP combined: 38.7–39.8 mpg (sDrive20i), 35.3 mpg (M40i) | WLTP combined: 48.8 mpg (A 180), 33.3 mpg (A 35), 30.8 mpg (A 45 S) |
| CO2 emissions | 161–164 g/km (sDrive20i), 180 g/km (M40i), WLTP combined | 131 g/km (A 180), 193 g/km (A 35), 208 g/km (A 45 S), WLTP combined |
| Practicality | ||
| Body | Convertible | Hatchback |
| Seats | 2 | 5 (better) |
| Boot | 281 litres | 350 litres (better) |
| Length | 4,324 mm | 4,428 mm |
| Width | 1,864 mm | 1,796 mm |
| Weight | – | From 1,464 kg |
| Boot | 281 litres | 350 litres (A 180); 370 litres (AMG A 35 and A 45 S) |
| Towing | – | 1,400 kg braked (A 180), 1,800 kg (A 35), 1,500 kg (A 45 S) |
| Size | 4,324 mm long, 1,864 mm wide (2,024 mm with mirrors), 1,304 mm high; 2,470 mm wheelbase; EC unladen weight including a 75 kg driver is 1,525 kg (sDrive20i), 1,640 kg (M40i) | 4,428 mm long (4,447 mm A 35, 4,453 mm A 45 S), 1,796 mm wide without mirrors (1,797 mm A 35, 1,850 mm A 45 S; 1,992 mm with mirrors), 1,423 mm high (1,407 mm A 35, 1,414 mm A 45 S); kerb weight 1,464 kg (A 180), 1,657 kg (A 35), 1,710 kg (A 45 S) |

