Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 14–24mm f/2.8G ED vs Nikon NIKKOR Z 14-24mm f/2.8 S

Every spec side by side, from each maker's published figures.

Better figure, where one is clearly better

AF-S NIKKOR 14–24mm f/2.8G ED compared with NIKKOR Z 14-24mm f/2.8 S
NikonAF-S NIKKOR 14–24mm f/2.8G EDNikonNIKKOR Z 14-24mm f/2.8 S
Overview
ReleasedNovember 2007November 2020
Optics
Lens typeZoomZoom
Focal length14–24 mm14–24 mm
Maximum aperturef/2.8f/2.8
Minimum aperturef/22f/22
Optical construction14 elements in 11 groupsSixteen elements in eleven groups
Special elementsTwo ED glass elements and three aspherical elementsFour ED and three aspherical elements
CoatingsNano Crystal CoatNano Crystal Coat, ARNEO coat and fluorine-coated front element
Aperture detailConstant f/2.8 maximum aperture throughout the zoom range; G-type automatic diaphragmConstant f/2.8 maximum; f/22 minimum
DiaphragmNine rounded bladesNine rounded blades
Angle of viewFX and 35 mm film 114°–84°; DX 90°–61°FX 114°–84°; DX 90°–61°
Mount and compatibility
MountsNikon F mountNikon Z mount
Image circleFull frameFull frame
CompatibilityNikon F mount with full-frame/FX coverage; also usable on DXNikon Z mount; FX and DX cameras; DX gives the angle of view of a 21–36 mm zoom on full frame
Focus and stabilisation
AutofocusYesYes
Minimum focus distance0.28 m0.28 m
Maximum magnification–0.13×
Optical stabilisationNoNo
Autofocus detailInternal focusing with an ultrasonic motor; Nikon USA identifies Silent Wave Motor. Manual focus override via M/A modeStepping-motor autofocus, as Digital Camera World describes; Nikon states smooth, quiet operation
Focus distance detailMinimum 0.28 m at 18–24 mm; Nikon Japan specifies 0.3 m below 18 mmInternal focusing; minimum 0.28 m from focal plane at all zoom positions
Magnification detailNikon UK publishes a maximum reproduction ratio of 1/6.7, while the current Japanese table gives 0.14×; both are retained here without silently equating themMaximum reproduction ratio 0.13× at 24 mm
Stabilisation detailNo optical VR, confirmed by Digital Camera WorldNo optical stabilisation, as Digital Camera World confirms; compatible bodies can provide sensor-shift stabilisation
Video features–Nikon describes reduced focus breathing and reduced focus shift while zooming; smooth aperture control via the control ring
Design
Dust and moisture resistant–Yes
Filter diameter–112 mm
Maximum diameter98 mm88.5 mm
Length131.5 mm124.5 mm
Weight1,000 g650 g (better)
ControlsZoom ring, focus ring, distance window and M/A–M switch; ePHOTOzine finds both rings smooth with short focus-ring travelZoom ring, focus ring, separate programmable control ring, L-Fn button, A/M switch and DISP button; OLED shows focal length, aperture, focus distance and depth of field
Zoom designRotating zoom ring with focal-length markings at 14, 15, 16, 18, 20 and 24 mm–
Filter detailNo standard screw-in filter attachment. Digital Camera World notes specialist external filter systems can be used with a dedicated adapter112 mm screw-on filters attach through supplied HB-97 specialised hood; rear slot accepts gel filters. No direct front filter thread on the bare lens
Weather resistanceePHOTOzine identifies a rubber seal at the mount and Digital Camera World describes weather seals. The maker tables do not define broader protection, so no general rating is assignedExtensive sealing around moving barrel parts and an aluminium-alloy mount, according to Nikon UK
Dimensions detailApproximately 98 mm maximum diameter × 131.5 mm length from the lens mountApproximately 88.5 × 124.5 mm, distance to end of lens measured from camera lens mount flange
Weight detailNikon UK specifies approximately 1,000 g; the current Japanese table specifies approximately 970 g. The UK figure is retainedApproximately 650 g
Lens hoodFixed hood around the curved front elementHB-96 standard hood and HB-97 filter-support hood included
In the boxSlip-on front cap, rear cap and CL-M3 semi-soft case; Nikon Japan's shop identifies the rear cap as LF-1LC-Z1424 and LC-K104 front caps, LF-N1 rear cap, HB-96 and HB-97 hoods, and CL-C2 case
Release detailNikon USA stated November 2007 availability; Nikon Japan's shop records 30 November 2007. Month precision is retained because the US first-sale day is not givenNikon USA specifies November 2020 availability; month precision retained

More comparisons