Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 600mm f/4E FL ED VR vs Nikon NIKKOR Z 600mm f/4 TC VR S

Every spec side by side, from each maker's published figures.

Better figure, where one is clearly better

AF-S NIKKOR 600mm f/4E FL ED VR compared with NIKKOR Z 600mm f/4 TC VR S
NikonAF-S NIKKOR 600mm f/4E FL ED VRNikonNIKKOR Z 600mm f/4 TC VR S
Overview
ReleasedJuly 2015November 2022
Optics
Lens typePrimePrime
Focal length600 mm600 mm
Maximum aperturef/4f/4
Minimum aperturef/22f/32
Optical construction16 elements in 12 groups plus one protective glass element26 elements in 20 groups, including seven elements in four groups in the built-in teleconverter
Special elementsFour ED elements and two fluorite elementsThree ED elements, one super-ED element, two fluorite elements and two SR elements including the built-in converter
CoatingsNano Crystal Coat; fluorine coating on the protective glassMeso Amorphous Coat, Nano Crystal Coat and fluorine coating on the front element
Aperture detail–f/4–32 without the built-in teleconverter; f/5.6–45 with it engaged
DiaphragmNine rounded blades; electromagnetic aperture controlNine rounded blades; electromagnetic aperture control
Angle of viewFX 4°10′; DX 2°40′FX 4°10′ at 600 mm and 3° at 840 mm; DX 2°40′ and 2° respectively
Mount and compatibility
MountsNikon F mountNikon Z mount
Image circleFull frameFull frame
CompatibilityCPU-equipped E-type Nikon F lens; electromagnetic aperture control restricts compatibility with some older DSLRs–
Teleconverter supportOriginal Nikon announcement lists TC-14E, TC-17E and TC-20E series; autofocus operation depends on the converter and camera aperture supportBuilt-in 1.4× converter selects 600 mm or 840 mm; Nikon UK also confirms compatibility with Nikon Z TC-1.4x and TC-2.0x converters
Focus and stabilisation
AutofocusYesYes
Minimum focus distance4.4 m4.3 m
Maximum magnification0.14×0.14×
Optical stabilisationYesYes
Autofocus detailInternal focusing with ultrasonic motor; autofocus and manual focusSilky Swift VCM with optical ABS encoder and internal focusing; FULL and infinity–10 m focus limiter positions
Focus distance detailMinimum focal-plane distance 4.4 m; focus limiter selects FULL or infinity–10 mMinimum focal-plane distance 4.3 m with or without the built-in converter; Cameralabs measured approximately 4.12 m in manual focus
Magnification detail–Maker 0.14× at 600 mm, used in the main specifications; 0.2× with the built-in converter engaged
Stabilisation detailLens-shift VR rated 4.0 stops under CIPA conditions on an FX DSLR; NORMAL and SPORT modes, with tripod vibration reduction supportedLens-shift VR rated 5.0 stops under CIPA conditions on an FX mirrorless camera in NORMAL mode, built-in converter disabled; 5.5 stops with Z9 Synchro VR
Video features–Maker breathing-suppression claim; Cameralabs observes visible focus breathing and recommends refocusing after switching the built-in converter
Design
Dust and moisture resistantYesYes
Filter diameter40.5 mm46 mm
Maximum diameter166 mm165 mm
Length432 mm437 mm
Weight3,810 g3,260 g (better)
ControlsReviews describe A/M, M/A and M focusing modes and four configurable buttons for AF-ON, AF lock or focus memory recallConfigurable control ring, L-Fn controls, Memory Set button and Fn ring for focus recall, A–M switch and lockable built-in converter lever
Filter detail40.5 mm drop-in filter system, not a front screw-in thread46 mm drop-in filter system, not a front screw-in thread
Weather resistanceOriginal Nikon announcement describes sealing and gaskets against the elements; no waterproof rating statedMaker sealing around moving parts and mount gasket; protection is not guaranteed in all conditions
Dimensions detailApproximately 166 mm maximum diameter × 432 mm from the mount flangeApproximately 165 mm maximum diameter × 437 mm from the mount flange
Weight detail–Approximately 3,260 g; Cameralabs reports an additional 248 g for the hood
Tripod mountTripod collar and foot; a shorter monopod foot is suppliedRotating tripod collar and foot; Cameralabs notes the standard foot lacks an Arca-Swiss profile
In the boxNikon UK lists slip-on front cap, LF-4 rear cap, HK-40 hood, 40.5 mm NC filter, CT-608 case, LN-2 strap and monopod collarNikon Japan lists LC-K107 front cap, LF-N1 rear cap, HK-43 hood, LN-3 or LN-4 strap and CL-L3 case
Release detailNikon US specified mid-July 2015 retail availability; the 2 July announcement is not used as the first-sale dateNikon Japan records 25 November 2022 release, following its planned delivery start on that date; this is the Japanese retail date

More comparisons