Apple Magic Keyboard with Numeric Keypad (Lightning) vs Logitech MX Keys S

Every spec side by side, from each maker's published figures.

Only show differences

Better figure, where one is clearly better

Share comparison

Magic Keyboard with Numeric Keypad (Lightning) compared with MX Keys S

	AppleMagic Keyboard with Numeric Keypad (Lightning)	LogitechMX Keys S
Overview
Released
Released	June 2017	June 2023
Typing
Layout
Layout	Full size	Full size
Switches
Switches	Scissor	Scissor
Key travel
Key travel	–	1.8 mm
Backlight
Backlight	None	White
Automatic backlight
Automatic backlight	–	Yes
Keys labelled for
Keys labelled for	Mac	Mac, Windows and more
Touch ID
Touch ID	No	No
Switches
Switches	Scissor mechanism beneath each key, with a low-profile design	Scissor switches with 60 g actuation force, rated for 10 million keystrokes (function keys 5 million)
Keycaps
Keycaps	–	Spherically dished keys shaped for fingertips
Layouts
Layouts	–	English UK, English International, Belgian, Croatian/Slovenian, Czech/Slovakian, Danish/Norwegian/Swedish/Finnish, French, German, Hebrew, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish, Swiss, Ukrainian (UK store); MX Keys S for Mac in English UK, English International, French, German and Swiss
Backlight
Backlight	–	A hand proximity sensor turns it on and an ambient light sensor sets the level; seven levels; stays off in bright rooms and below 10% battery; duration and brightness adjustable in Logi Options+
Special keys
Special keys	Numeric keypad, full-size arrow keys, document navigation controls and multimedia keys; F1–F19, Home, End, Page Up, Page Down and forward Delete are described in iMore's exact-model hands-on	Dictation, emoji and microphone mute/unmute keys in the F row; Easy-Switch keys; Fn + Esc swaps media keys and F-keys; legends for both Windows and Mac (a Mac layout on MX Keys S for Mac)
Connections and battery
Connects by
Connects by	Bluetooth	Bluetooth and USB receiver
Devices it switches between
Devices it switches between	1	3 (better)
Power
Power	Rechargeable	Rechargeable
Battery life (maker's claim)
Battery life (maker's claim)	–	Up to 5 months
With the backlight on
With the backlight on	–	Up to 10 days
Receiver
Receiver	–	Logi Bolt USB receiver included (not compatible with other Logitech receivers); MX Keys S for Mac has none in the box but works with one, which Logitech advises for Macs with FileVault on
Battery life detail
Battery life detail	About a month or more between charges, according to Apple; tested in April 2017 with preproduction keyboards and shipping iMacs. Not an upper-bound battery-life claim.	Rechargeable 1500 mAh Li-Po; Logitech quotes up to 10 days with its default backlight settings or up to 5 months with backlighting off
Charging
Charging	Built-in rechargeable battery; the included Lightning-to-USB cable charges from a Mac or USB power adapter and automatically pairs with a Mac	USB-C port at the top right; usable while charging; USB-A to USB-C cable (USB-C to USB-C with MX Keys S for Mac)
Works with
Works with	Bluetooth-enabled Mac with macOS 10.12.4 or later; iOS devices with iOS 10.3 or later. Apple's guide requires removing the existing pairing before pairing with a different Mac.	Bluetooth with Windows 10, 11 or later, macOS 10.15 or later, iPadOS 14 or later, Android 8.0 or later, Linux and ChromeOS; Logi Bolt with Windows 10, 11 or later, macOS 10.15 or later, Linux and ChromeOS; MX Keys S for Mac lists macOS 10.15 or later, iOS 14 or later and iPadOS 14 or later
Software
Software	Keyboard preferences configure modifier keys, shortcuts and input sources and show battery level	Logi Options+ (Windows and macOS) for Smart Actions, key customisation and backlight settings; Logitech Flow with a Flow-enabled Logitech mouse
Design
Weight
Weight	390 g (better)	810 g
Width × depth × height
Width × depth × height	418.7 × 114.9 × 10.9 mm	430.2 × 131.63 × 20.5 mm
Materials
Materials	–	Low-carbon aluminium key-module bracket; plastic parts include 26% (Graphite, Space Gray) or 11% (Pale Gray) certified post-consumer recycled plastic
Size
Size	Height 0.41–1.09 cm, width 41.87 cm and depth 11.49 cm; Apple's 0.39 kg weight varies by configuration and manufacturing process	–
Colours
Colours	Silver with white keys in the retained UK store listing	Graphite, Pale Gray (UK store; Black also sold in the US); MX Keys S for Mac in Space Gray and Pale Grey
In the box
In the box	Keyboard and Lightning-to-USB-A cable. TechCrunch's 5 June 2017 launch report records immediate shipping; the retained maker sheet does not give a release date. This entry covers the Lightning model without Touch ID.	Keyboard, Logi Bolt USB receiver, USB-A to USB-C charging cable, documentation (also sold with MX Palm Rest); MX Keys S for Mac comes with a USB-C to USB-C cable and no receiver
Warranty
Warranty	–	2-year limited hardware warranty (UK)